The Latest Phone Scams are Personalized

Matt Mizenko talks about the latest phone scams and how you can protect yourself.

Scam texts and phone calls are getting harder and harder to spot. Yes, scammers are always finding new tricks. But these days, they also have access to a lot more information about us and tools that can help them use it. The latest phone scams aren’t quantity-over-quality operations. They’re leveraging AI tools and personal data to become almost indistinguishable from legitimate messages. That means some of the old scam safety advice doesn’t work anymore. It’s crucial to know what tips are outdated – and what you can do to make yourself a more difficult target.


See Scammers Know You with Matt Mizenko for a complete transcript of the Easy Prey podcast episode.

Matt Mizenko has over two decades of experience in the telephony space. He’s spent more than half of that career fighting frauds happening over texts and phone calls. Currently, he is the managing director at Nomorobo, a company that provides call and text protection services for both individuals and businesses.

The Current State of Phone Scams

Impostor and impersonation scams are happening a lot right now. These are when the scammer calls or texts pretending to be a person (or a company) they aren’t. A very common type is pretending to be from your bank or from Amazon asking you to verify a very large purchase you didn’t make. Before the midterm elections, there were also a lot of impostors pretending to be from political campaigns asking for donations. A common one this time of year is healthcare open enrollment scams. It’s especially common in years where big things have changed. Scammers take advantage of people’s confusion to trick them into handing over money or information.

Scams happen all year long. But they increase during the holidays. Not just things like Amazon scams or shopping-related ones, either. FedEx and UPS impostor scams increase, too. November and December are busy times for most people. There’s a lot of things going on in everyone’s life. And it’s not uncommon to get packages you weren’t expecting. A very common tactic is for a scammer to call and claim to be from a shipping company, but it’s just a few dollars short on postage, and ask you to cover the postage. It’s a combination of something that seems plausible (someone’s probably sending you a gift), catching you during a busy time, and not asking for a ton of money.

Some people assume scammers would want to get a lot of money. If they’re just asking $10 or $20 for shipping, surely that wouldn’t be profitable. But if they get 10,000 people to pay $20 for a package that doesn’t exist, that’s a good profit for them! This combination of urgency, reasonableness, and catching you when you’re busy or stressed makes it a profitable time of year for scammers.

The Latest Phone Scams are Targeted

The media has talked a lot about AI lately. Obviously, the rise of AI also affects scams. There’s been a lot of talk about the “grandparent scams” where scammers use AI-generated voices to sound like a grandchild (or other relative) and ask for money to help them out of a tight spot. Those do happen, but they’re not as common as you might think from the news coverage.

The latest phone scams aren’t using AI voices as much as they’re using what Matt thinks of as “traditional” AI. Scammers aren’t asking AI to make the calls. They’re asking AI to make them a list of targets. They can tell it to come up with a thousand people between the ages of 55 and 65 who are Bank of America customers and who have at least $500,000. AI can dig up a ton of personal information on each of those people. Commercial AI won’t do those kinds of things, but criminals are setting up their own AI tools that will.

It’s become very easy for these criminals to use new tools to go out and get [personal] information.

Matt Mizenko

They end up with a list of targets who they know a lot about. They can then use that information in phone scams. It’s easy to be suspicious when a caller asks you for your social security number. You’re much more likely to trust them if they instead tell you your social security number and ask you to confirm it. Thanks to social media and data breaches, it’s easy for criminals to get a lot of personal information. The volume of phone scams has gone down because they don’t need to call randomly. When they call you, they already know a lot about you.

Advice that Doesn’t Work Against the Latest Phone Scams

Scammers are always adapting their tactics and finding new strategies to steal from people. They also know what advice people are hearing about avoiding scams. So they’re always adjusting their tactics to make the old advice irrelevant. AI has made some of that easier. The latest phone scams find ways around some of the more common or well-known pieces of advice.

Don’t Say Specific Things

For a while, one piece of advice was that you shouldn’t say specific things, including “Yes” or “No,” on the phone. The idea was that callers would record the call, alter the recording to make it sound like you agreed to (or said no to) something, and then use that to exploit you or charge you money.

Some common advice doesn't actually protect you from the latest phone scams.

But the reality is that it doesn’t make a difference. Legitimate telemarketers can get a little shady, but they ultimately want to make money within the law, so they’re not going to stoop to such obviously illegal practices. And criminals don’t need a record of you agreeing – they’ll either manipulate you into helping them or do whatever they want without even involving you. If you suspect someone is trying to manipulate you into saying a specific thing, it’s safest just to hang up.

Don’t Speak First

This piece of advice was that when you answer the phone, don’t speak first – wait to see what the other person says, and if it’s suspicious, hang up without speaking. This is based on the idea that it’s dangerous for a scammer to even hear your voice, because they could record it and use it to clone your voice. But in reality, it doesn’t actually matter what you say on a call. The latest phone scams aren’t trying to collect voice samples from a call. If they want to clone your voice, they’re going to your social media accounts to find video you’ve posted. And except for very specific scams, criminals don’t bother cloning voices.

Listen for Dead Air

This piece of advice says that if there’s three to five seconds of silence before the caller starts speaking, that’s a sign that something fishy is going on. But that’s not necessarily the case. That dead air indicates you’re waiting in a queue to talk to a representative. Call centers use that kind of technology a lot. They have auto-dialers that will dial five or more numbers at a time. Your call only connects to a person at the call center once you pick up. But getting connected takes a little bit of time. That’s why the dead air happens.

It’s not necessarily nefarious. Scam call centers use that kind of technology. But so do legitimate call centers. So it’s not an indication that you’re going to be talking to a scammer. It’s just an indication that you’re going to be talking to someone at a call center.

Sending Calls to Voicemail is a Good Idea

A lot of phones have an option to send all calls from numbers not in your contacts straight to voicemail. It’s a great tactic because a legitimate person is most likely going to leave a voicemail, and you’ll be able to see if it’s someone you do want to talk to. Scammers don’t tend to leave voicemails. So it filters a lot of them out.

Screening calls is also a great way to defend against the latest phone scams. One of Nomorobo’s features is screening callers. The system asks them to explain who they are and why they’re calling. Then you can decide if that’s someone you actually want to talk to. Most people calling with something you don’t want aren’t going to bother with that. That’s not just scammers, but also telemarketers and spammers. It’s just another barrier you can put between yourself and the criminals targeting you. And the more of those barriers you can put up, the better.

The more things that you can put up between you and the bad guys, the better off you’re going to be.

Matt Mizenko

The only downside of filtering everything or sending everything to voicemail are those occasional situations where you have a plumber coming who calls you on his way and it goes directly to voicemail. Matt had that situation happen recently – he was waiting on an air conditioner repairman and got a call from a number labeled “Spam Likely.” He took a risk, thinking it might be the repairman, and he was right. There are cases when you really want to get a particular call but it gets blocked or filtered out. There’s not a perfect solution to that yet. It’s something experts are still working on as they try to protect against the latest phone scams.

False Positives are Worse than False Negatives

Matt considers Nomorobo and similar phone protection companies to be a utility. That means people think about it differently. You probably don’t think of your electric company most of the time. When you flip a light switch and the light comes on, you don’t think about how good of a job your electric company is doing. You only think about it when you’re paying the bill – or when the power in your house goes out.

The same is true with Nomorobo. If your call protection is working, you aren’t thinking about them. If you didn’t get a call you really needed because Nomorobo blocked it, now you’re thinking about them. And it’s not in a positive way. They’ve done customer surveys and found that people are more concerned with false positives than false negatives. Blocking a call someone wanted makes people more upset than letting a spam call through every once in a while.

Nomorobo looks at a lot of signals to try and identify a call’s trustworthiness. Public service things like utility companies, hospitals, schools, and police departments provide approved lists of all numbers they call from. Companies can look at that and the STIR/SHAKEN header that accompanies every phone call to determine if it’s spoofed. They can also look at calls on an aggregate basis to see which numbers people answer, which they don’t, and how long they spend on calls. That also indicates whether a call is worth talking to. All of these methods help screen out the latest phone scams while still letting the calls you do want through.

Resources for Fighting the Latest Phone Scams

Nomorobo does have a phone protection and call screening service that they sell. It includes apps on both iOS and Android. But they also do a lot in the spam-fighting community. They have a page for details about the latest phone scams and advice for protection at nomorobo.com/fraudfighters. That includes actual scam call recordings and transcripts.

Looking at this kind of thing can help you keep up with the latest trends in phone scams and find ways to protect yourself. Scam calls and texts about unpaid tolls were big for a while, but it was pretty short-lived because people shared a lot about it so it stopped being effective. Learning about scammer tactics and telling others will keep everyone safer. Nomorobo makes this information available, and you can share it with your loved ones to make everyone aware of what’s going on, warning signs to watch for, and the current scammer ploys.

The more you know, the better informed you are, obviously the safer you’ll be.

Matt Mizenko

If you’ve been caught by a scam, it’s important to get help quickly. Nomorobo works closely with the AARP to fight scams. One story Matt heard from the AARP was someone who was scammed out of over $100,000 from their retirement account. They didn’t report it because of the panic and shame. But when tax time came, the IRS said the loss was an early withdrawal and they owed taxes and penalties. The situation was eventually resolved, but if they had reported it right away, they would have already had documentation. As much as it sucks, if someone scams you, report it and get help right away.

Learn more about Matt Mizenko and Nomorobo at nomorobo.com.